The Empire’s “Othello Trap”: How Barbarian Generals Became the Gravediggers of Civilization


“Civilization” prides itself as a beacon, yet repeatedly hands the torch to “barbarians.” “Advanced” societies boast impregnable walls, yet personally open the gates to the “backward.”

From the Han and Tang dynasties to Rome, the same script plays out again and again: warriors from nomadic tribes and chieftains from despotic frontiers are recruited into the core of “civilized” military and political systems, granted high office and command of armies—only to plunge millennia-old empires into the abyss through rebellion, sackings, or depositions.
Literature foresaw it long ago; history merely confirmed it. When an arrogant “Othello” is promoted but never truly accepted, destruction is only a matter of time.Act I: The Han-Tang Nightmare of the “Five Barbarians”Liu Yuan: The Xiongnu Officer Who Ignited the Upheaval of the Five BarbariansTo fill the military vacuum left by the War of the Eight Princes, the Western Jin court summoned Liu Yuan, a descendant of the Xiongnu, to Luoyang and appointed him a northern frontier officer. Fluent in Chinese and versed in military strategy, he was never regarded as a “Jin man.” In 304 CE, he proclaimed himself King of Han, unleashing the Upheaval of the Five Barbarians. The Western Jin fell in 316 CE; Luoyang and Chang’an were reduced to ashes, and the northern Han lands plunged into a century of slaughter and fragmentation.Shi Siming: The Sogdian Slave Who Rose to Regional CommanderTo resist external threats, Emperor Xuanzong of Tang elevated Shi Siming, a man of Sogdian “barbarian” origin who had once been a slave, to the post of military governor of Fanyang. From servitude he came to command three provinces. In 755 CE, he joined An Lushan in rebellion, later murdering An’s son to proclaim himself Emperor of Yan. Chang’an fell twice, the population plummeted by thirty million, and the Tang slid from prosperity to decline, ushering in a century of warlordism.Nurhaci: The Jurchen Bodyguard Under Li ChengliangTo pacify the frontiers, Ming general Li Chengliang took the Jianzhou Jurchen leader Nurhaci as a personal guard, teaching him Chinese characters, firearms, and formations. Nurhaci quietly memorized Ming weaknesses. In 1616 he founded the Later Jin; in 1619 he annihilated forty thousand Ming troops at the Battle of Sarhū. The northeastern gate was flung open, and two decades later Qing armies stormed the pass, toppling the Ming.
Han, Tang, and Rome all followed the same path: civilized empires, weakened by internal strife, recruited “barbarians” to fill military posts—yet forgot that loyalty cannot be purchased with battlefield merit.
Act II: Rome’s “Foederati” CollapseArminius: The Roman Citizen’s Ambush in the Teutoburg ForestIn the early 1st century CE, the Cherusci youth Arminius was granted Roman citizenship and appointed commander of auxiliary troops, mastering Latin and tactics. In 9 CE he lured three legions under Varus into the Teutoburg Forest and annihilated them. Emperor Augustus wailed in Rome: “Varus, give me back my legions!” Roman expansion east of the Rhine was halted forever.Stilicho: The Half-Vandal Regent’s Fatal Balancing ActIn 395 CE, Stilicho—half-Vandal by blood—became supreme commander of the Western Roman army, guardian of the boy-emperor Honorius. He repelled Visigothic invasions yet was distrusted by the Senate for his “barbarian” lineage. Executed in 408 CE, his death removed the last restraint on his brother-in-law Alaric. Two years later, Alaric sacked Rome—the Eternal City, breached by foreigners for the first time in eight hundred years.Alaric: From “Master of Soldiers” to PlundererThe Visigothic leader Alaric had been granted the titles of Count of Illyricum and Master of Soldiers, leading auxiliary forces for Rome. Unpaid wages and racial contempt chilled his heart. On August 24, 410 CE, he stormed the city; three days of looting followed, the emperor’s sister was abducted, and Rome’s prestige crumbled.Gaiseric: The Fourteen-Day Sack by a North African AllyIn 429 CE, the Vandals under Gaiseric settled in North Africa with Rome’s recognition as “allies.” Ten years later they seized Carthage. In 455 CE, invited (or deceived) into the port of Rome to “protect the empress,” Gaiseric’s fleet sacked the city for fourteen days. The imperial family was taken captive, Mediterranean grain routes severed.Odoacer: The Barbarian Commander Who Deposed the Last EmperorIn 476 CE, Odoacer—Scirian-Herulian by blood—commanded the Italian legions and held the rank of patrician. He deposed the boy-emperor Romulus Augustulus, sent him to retirement in Naples, and proclaimed himself King of Italy. The Western Roman Empire ended in silence; a thousand years of central authority dissolved beneath a barbarian spear.Act III: Literature’s Prophecy and EchoOthello: The Moorish General’s Venetian TragedyIn Shakespeare’s play, the African “barbarian” Othello is appointed governor and general by the Venetian Senate to defend civilization. Victorious in battle, he is nevertheless branded a “barbarian horse.” A single whisper from Iago drives him to strangle his wife Desdemona and take his own life. Venice’s “civilized” marriage and order collapse with him.Macbeth: The Scottish Border Warrior’s Path to RegicideThe “wild” Scottish border warrior Macbeth begins as a general under King Duncan, then—seduced by witches—murders the king and seizes the throne. Civil war slaughters nobles, the dynasty crumbles, and ruin follows. Shakespeare warns: once backward ambition ascends a civilized throne, tyranny and collapse ensue.Jugurtha: Sallust’s Mirror of CorruptionThe Numidian prince Jugurtha served in Roman armies, learning bribery and intrigue. Returning home, he murdered his king and sparked a seven-year war. Sallust laments in The Jugurthine War: Rome recruits “barbarians,” only to have barbarians corrode the soul of the Senate in turn.
Literature anticipated history, staging the “Othello Trap” in advance: the outsider is elevated but never embraced; civilization prides itself on tolerance yet plants the seeds of its own destruction.
Epilogue: The Price of ArroganceThe Roman historian Tacitus wrote in his Annals:
“They learn our language, our laws, our strategy… yet retain their barbarian souls.”
Han, Tang, and Rome—separated by a millennium—stumbled into the same abyss:
  1. Internal chaos empties the army; “barbarians” are recruited to fill the ranks.
  2. Battlefield glory earns high office, but never equality or respect.
  3. Cultural estrangement and political exclusion ignite rebellion.
  4. Core cities fall; central authority disintegrates.
  5. The beacon of civilization is extinguished by the very torch it handed over.
When an empire gives the sword to outsiders, trust to foreigners, yet withholds belonging—
“Othello” ceases to be a tragic figure and becomes history’s executioner.

评论

  1. Charlie Chan2025年11月2日 20:12

    Perhaps we should add Barack Obama and Mamdani to this list of cases.

    回复删除

发表评论

此博客中的热门博文

The five stages and strategies of South Africanization of the United States

图片
In today's globalized world, the United States, as the beacon of Western democracy, faces unprecedented internal challenges. From racial tensions and economic inequality to surging waves of immigration, these issues are not isolated but interwoven into a complex web that subtly reveals an unsettling similarity—to South Africa's post-apartheid era. After ending apartheid in 1994, South Africa should have ushered in prosperity, yet it has been mired in long-term stagnation due to failed land reforms, economic decline, and persistent racial antagonism: forced expropriation of white farmers' land led to a sharp drop in agricultural output, gun control policies exacerbated skyrocketing crime rates, and government corruption along with media control further eroded social trust. Today, certain social dynamics in the United States seem to be replaying this trajectory: the infiltration of extreme left-wing ideologies, the proliferation of identity politics, and the cultural shoc...
阅读全文

The Third Way of Governing a Diverse Nation：Black people have the right to establish their own autonomous state

图片
    The fate of Britain after World War II—victorious yet defeated—stemmed not only from the successful implementation of the Soviet-American strategy to suppress Britain but, more critically, from Britain’s inability to devise a system capable of establishing an acceptable order for the vast territories and diverse peoples conquered during its imperialist era. In essence, the challenges confronting the United States and European nations today mirror those faced by Britain post-World War II: how to create an order that citizens of different cultures and ethnicities are willing to accept. In my judgment, the Trump administration is clearly incapable of achieving this task. Indeed, the nature of the problems it faces parallels those encountered by the British government after World War II, as well as by Caesar and Augustus in ancient Rome. Under pressure from the United States and the Soviet Union, post-war Britain opted for contraction, shrinking into a small, single-ethnicity ...
阅读全文

The overthrow of the white South African regime should be seen as aggression：Correspondence between the increase in illegal immigration in South Africa and the collapse of white rule in South Africa

图片
South Africa does indeed face an immigration issue, and the increase in foreign immigrants may have been closely tied to the overthrow of white rule (apartheid), particularly as their presence and involvement played a role in this historical shift. Below, I’ll analyze the correspondence between the rise in foreign immigration and the collapse of white rule in South Africa, as per your request, drawing on historical data and context. 1. Historical Context of Immigration in South Africa South Africa has been a hub for labor migration in southern Africa since the 19th century, especially during the mining boom (gold and diamonds), when large numbers of black workers from neighboring countries like Mozambique, Lesotho, and Eswatini were recruited. During the apartheid era (1948-1994), these immigrants were tightly controlled, treated as temporary labor without permanent residency rights, and deported after their contracts ended. Meanwhile, white immigrants, primarily from Europe, were priv...
阅读全文